Sustainability

Changing bad habits

by Laurel Brunner | 20/07/2023
Changing bad habits

Laurel Brunner discusses the benefits of publishers working with printers to lower their negative impact on the environment. Laurel writes that in other print sectors like labels and packaging, signage and commercial print innovators are currently exploiting digital on demand production and delivery.

If we wanted to point a finger at the worst offenders when it comes to environmental inefficiency, which print sector would we choose? Labels and packaging produce phenomenal quantities of waste. Commercial print is also responsible for sending tonnes of paper for landfill or incineration. The signage business also produces a lot of material that once it is used, is mostly not reused so it turns into trash. But in all of these cases there are mechanisms for recycling or reuse and support for the circular economy, at least in principle. Users of the prints including consumers have options for sending material for recycling.

But book publishers can rightly claim the worst offender crown, because pulping of unsold books is built into their business models. And they do not have a habit of accurately estimating print volumes. It’s as if no one has noticed that the price per copy afforded by scale is counter to an environmentally responsible process. The thinking appears to be that because per copy prices get cheaper the more you print, it is ok to not take a more careful approach to estimating.

Even if authors want to claim their unsold copies in order to give them to schools, libraries, charities and second-hand shops, they cannot unless they buy the copies outright. There is no mechanism through which publishers large and small support reuse and redistribution. From the very large such as Penguin Random House through to the minnows such as Unbound, authors who want to take responsibility for the reuse of their books are forbidden from doing so unless they buy the copies themselves.

Book publishers are in the game to make money, just as pretty much every other print buyer is. It’s understandable that unwanted volumes should be turned into a revenue stream whenever possible. But this outmoded model has to change. There are two obvious flaws in this business model in the context of today’s production technology options. Not least of these is the reluctance to upgrade book production, ordering and distribution to a print on demand model. That takes money of course, but book publishing is highly profitable for the majors who are best place to drive change. And there doesn’t even seem to be a move towards hybrid production, whereby both conventional analogue and production on demand via digital printing are supported. It is a disgrace.

What the majors and the minors should be doing is investing in their knowledge of what is possible with print on demand. Working with networks of print service providers would allow publishers to produce books close to their point of use, either end users or the local bookshops. Using variable data technologies they could even add value through personalisation or alternative endings say, or long and short versions. It seems so obvious. It is tragic that developers have created so many amazing opportunities for new book publishing and reuse models that are ignored. In other print sectors such as labels and packaging, signage and commercial print, innovators are exploiting digital on demand production and delivery. Book publishers meanwhile stick with what they know and what they can exploit, environmental impact or not.

Source information: This article was produced by the Verdigris Project, an industry initiative intended to raise awareness of print’s positive environmental impact. This weekly commentary helps printing companies keep up to date with environmental standards, and how environmentally friendly business management can help improve their bottom lines. Verdigris is supported by the following companies: Agfa GraphicsEFIFespaFujifilmHPKodakMiraclonRicohSplash PRUnity Publishing and Xeikon

Header caption: Photo by Tom Hermans on Unsplash

by Laurel Brunner Back to News

Interested in joining our community?

Enquire today about joining your local FESPA Association or FESPA Direct

Enquire Today

Recent news

Why are FESPA events the ideal place for visionaries to meet? With Harold Klaren from EFKA
Signage

Why are FESPA events the ideal place for visionaries to meet? With Harold Klaren from EFKA

We speak to Harold Klaren, International Sales Manager at EFKA about visionaries in print. Harold shares why he believes FESPA events are the ideal place for visionareis to meet.

23-04-2025
Why are FESPA events the ideal place for visionaries to meet? With Harold Klaren from EFKA
NSELED to showcase Innovation and transformation at European Sign Expo 2025
Digital Signage

NSELED to showcase Innovation and transformation at European Sign Expo 2025

NSELED Europe, part of leading LED display technology provider NSE, will welcome visitors to its stand at the European Sign Expo 2025. Ahead of the event, we speak with Daniele Rocca, principal chief executive officer at NSELED Europe, about what to expect from the company as the official ‘Digital Screen Partner’ of the event.

22-04-2025
Why the Future of Print Is Personal – and What That Means for Your Business
Personalisation

Why the Future of Print Is Personal – and What That Means for Your Business

Minna Philipson, CMO at Gelato shares how the future of print is personal, driven by demands for tailored, localised, and on-demand products. Businesses must adapt, embracing software to streamline operations and building customer-centric brands. Personalisation is key to connection, requiring emotional storytelling and flexible operations to thrive in the evolving market.

22-04-2025
The latest sustainable solutions in non-digital signage
Signage

The latest sustainable solutions in non-digital signage

While by no means a new concept in the market, sustainability is becoming an increasingly important part of daily life for sign-making businesses. Here, Rob Fletcher shares some of the non-digital materials to help companies become more planet friendly.

21-04-2025