How to spot greenwashing

Laurel Brunner discusses the need to have a sliding scale for greenwashing regarding sustainability claims amongst companies.
Many graphic arts companies want to do their bit to help mitigate climate change. They might take it really seriously and be ISO 14001 (Environmental management systems) certified, or they might prefer to be a little looser in how they cut carbon and environmental impacts.
Either way they are faced with working with other companies, and evaluating their sustainability claims in some sort of context.
There ought to be some sort of sliding scale for greenwashing, running from nought to ten, with ten the most honest of claims. Zero would be untruthful or disingenuous sustainability claims and ten would be the justifiable and bulletproof sustainability boasts. That’s a start but what would be good examples of either extreme?
Let’s start with the fake ones. A German-French-Dutch consumer protection group called Foodwatch recently asked German consumers to nominate the most outrageous lie on packaging. Arla’s Bio-Weidemilch is one of five nominees. The longlife milk product’s package claims that it cuts CO2 emissions by an impressive 72%. According to Foodwatch, this is rubbish because only the packaging is produced in an environmentally friendly way, not the milk. Arla has apparently even invented a bogus eco-label for the product, so this has to be greenwashing of the worst kind.
Closer to home we recently had a press release from an inkjet printhead manufacturer boasting about its introduction of new paper-based packaging based on “fully recyclable and biodegradable cardboard”. Is there any other kind? Turning away from plastics to reduce plastics consumption by 1.2 tonnes per year is great, but it is not much more than responsible behaviour given the current plastics crisis. And mentioning that cardboard is biodegradable confirms that the company in question hasn’t taken the time to consider the initiative beyond its box-ticking benefits.
At the other extreme, where a claim is really solid and impressive we have any organisation in the graphics supply chain that has an ISO 14001 certification, especially for many years. ISO 14001 certification is gold standard but equally valid is the small business where owners and staff have put into place environmental impact mitigation measures. Even having an environmental policy in place demonstrates a commitment to environmental sustainability in the industry.
The only way to spot the cheats is to check their claims. Look behind what they are claiming and check out the details. If you can’t find any, ask and if you don’t get a proper response, take your business elsewhere. Sustainability is about building your business in a way that respects the environment and the planet’s need for industries and consumers to take more care.
Source information: This article was produced by the Verdigris Project, an industry initiative intended to raise awareness of print’s positive environmental impact. This weekly commentary helps printing companies keep up to date with environmental standards, and how environmentally friendly business management can help improve their bottom lines. Verdigris is supported by the following companies: Agfa Graphics, EFI, Fespa, Fujifilm, HP, Kodak, Miraclon, Ricoh, Spindrift, Splash PR, Unity Publishing and Xeikon.
Topics
Interested in joining our community?
Enquire today about joining your local FESPA Association or FESPA Direct
Recent news

Special Effects in DTF Will Make Your “Prints” More Memorable
The DTF market is expanding with new vendors and innovations like multi-head printers enabling diverse ink options (spot, neon). Decorative films offer streamlined special effects. Keypoint Intelligence tested metallic and glitter films, noting varied ease of use and wash durability. New technology using adhesive and foil directly promises further creative advancements in DTF.

SmartHub – Expectations, opportunities and why you should attend!
The SmartHub at Personalisation Experience 2025 in Berlin will showcase personalisation and smart production opportunities across industries like textiles. Featuring a Smart Factory Trail with brands like Inkcups and Trotec, and a conference with experts discussing AI, mass customisation, and profit strategies, it offers insights into reducing waste and boosting efficiency through digital methods. Panel sessions will explore growth, automation in textiles, and smart manufacturing.

How is AI revolutionising Large Format Print?
Nessan Clearly discusses how AI in print relies on data pattern matching, already enhancing software for large format providers. He predicts that this will result in increased AI integration in workflow planning, job queue management, colour correction, image upscaling, and predictive maintenance via sensors and vision systems, ultimately streamlining operations and offering greater flexibility.

One Ink for All? Exploring Pigment in Textile Printing
Digital textile printing faces complexity due to diverse substrates requiring specific inks. The industry seeks a universal ink, with pigment ink showing potential. While traditionally for natural fibres, advancements aim to broaden its application, simplify processes by reducing pre/post-treatment, and improve sustainability, though challenges like hand feel on garments remain.